AUTHOR’S NOTE: I was wondering whether there is a law or principle of “inevitability” that might be applied to the results of a tarot reading. I went looking and found that I was on the right track with David Hand’s “Law of Inevitability,” one of his postulated rules for the “Improbability Principle.” (See the link below.)
The Law of Inevitability
Something must happen
“The law of inevitability says that one of the complete set of all possible outcomes of a random event must occur. So, to see this law in action, we need to be able to list all the possible outcomes, at least in principle.”
As most conscientious diviners will agree, we can be so eager to distance ourself from any claim of certainty that a prediction we’ve made is 100% reliable that we may withhold insights that would have been useful to our client if we had been more sure of ourself (which only comes with constant study, practice and contemplation over a long period of time to reach even a semblance of Bob Dylan’s assertion [ed. by me] that “You don’t need to be a weatherman to see which way the wind blows”).
By protesting that the future isn’t “carved in stone” and backing away from commitment, we shield ourselves from the accusation that we don’t know what we we’re doing. Personally, I would rather be blamed for too much engagement than not enough since I can split philosophical hairs with the best of them. I once wrote an essay titled “Is Might Safer Than Must? – Thoughts on Risky Predictions” in which I observed:
“The cards pulled will generally offer one of three narrative arcs. They will:
– Convey a strong likelihood that the predicted outcome, whether favorable or unfavorable to the seeker, will come to pass;
– Just as vehemently declare the improbability of it transpiring (again, ‘for good or ill’);
– Withhold a ‘vote of confidence’ that either one will prevail as shown by an array of cards that veers first one way and then the other, producing an inconclusive result.
This tripartite disposition is the realm of the divinatory ‘tap-dancer’ who must step lively and lightly between the incentives and impediments, looking for insights that will aid in judging the message to decide whether it delivers a blessing or a curse, and then select which outlook to emphasize.”
In revisiting this post, I found it to be a marvel of equivocation in its view of predictive accuracy: something is likely to happen, but then again it might not and, even more problematic, we may not be able to tell if it will or won’t. Although I could have, I didn’t go into the “partial satisfaction” scenario where querents will get some of what they want and must let the rest go. That’s a bit too much “verbal tap-dancing” even for me, although as one of Hand’s “all possible outcomes” it would have to be considered under the Law of Inevitability.
Given these stipulations, I can’t imagine why anyone would want to sit for a reading, and certainly not why they would want to pay for one. As I said in the aforementioned essay:
“So yes, it’s much safer for the tarot reader to talk about tendencies and steer clear of certainties even if that waffling isn’t what the client wants to hear. An emerging trend won’t require that they jump in with both feet while an imperative doesn’t offer the luxury of choice.”
If this sounds like hedging, it most definitely is. When we don’t prevaricate to some extent, we can wind up being “damned if we do and damned if we don’t.” If we say with conviction “Yes, it will happen” regarding a favorable outlook when the answer should really be “No, it’s highly unlikely,” or advise the seeker “No, you’re safe” from an unfavorable augury when the correct forecast would be “Yes, you should worry,” we are at least irresponsible and may be negligent in our pronouncements. (I lay it at the feet of the “affirmation and empowerment” culture.) In either case we are doing our sitter a grave disservice if they act on our flawed counsel.
It may be time to trot out a version of “Pascal’s Wager:” It’s safer from a risk-mitigation standpoint to believe in the existence of a merciful God (purveyor of “happy endings”) when there isn’t one than it is to disbelieve in a vengeful God (bestower of “unhappy endings”) when there is one, or as Bob Dylan’s wrathful God warned Abraham in Highway 61 Revisited, “The next time you see me comin’ you better run.”
Although both overstatement and understatement can be damaging to the tarot reader’s professional credibility, this premise can be restated in divination language as:
“It’s safer to assume that a favorable outcome is likely to occur when in fact it isn’t going to happen (overstated positivism) than to predict that an unfavorable outcome will be averted when it will almost surely come to pass (understated negativism).”
In the first situation, seekers may be disabused of their hopes but they risk nothing by hoping in vain, so all they will suffer is disappointment (assuming they didn’t “bet the farm” on a stillborn venture that was never guaranteed to pay off), while in the second eventuality the reluctance to prepare for the future could be disastrous. It reminds me of the fable about “The Ant and The Grasshopper.” The Ant, knowing that Winter is coming, is getting ready for it while the Grasshopper – who anticipates an “Endless Summer” – frolics away in the sunshine with no thought for preparation.
So . . . based on what we see in the cards, do we tell the seeker to adopt the anticipatory strategy of the prudent Ant or the avoidance tactics of the cocky Grasshopper? As always, it depends on the “good or “ill” consequences of the projected outcome, but the carefree Grasshopper has more to lose than he realizes.
If I were a confirmed believer in “empowerment” with the tarot, I would read every positive card in the most auspicious way and every negative card from the least ominous perspective, thereby “lighting a fire under” the best scenario and attempting to “defuse” the worst one. With the industrious Ant, this would amount to underscoring the inevitability of his success, but with the lazy Grasshopper it would probably just roll off his back until he realizes too late that he can’t measure up and his best efforts will be nowhere near good enough. He will get a mocking “tip o’ the hat” and a “Baby, it’s cold outside” from the smug (and snug) Ant.
But I’m not so inclined and I refuse to be a cheerleader, instead approaching every reading in the most even-handed manner I can muster by judging the cards only on objective content, not on subjective inspiration value. The Ants among my clientele will still find reason to be encouraged while the Grasshoppers will just have to fend for themselves.